Skip to content
Printify vs Printed Mint

Printify vs Printed Mint: I Tested Both to Find the Best POD Platform

Printify and Printed Mint both promise to handle production and shipping so you can focus on building your brand, but they take very different approaches.

I’ve tested both platforms, comparing their catalogs, pricing, branding tools, and real-world reliability to help you figure out which one actually fits your business.

The twist in Printify vs Printed Mint: Printed Mint also fulfills Printify orders from Phoenix, Arizona. I priced the same candles and cutting boards both ways, and the cheapest route depends on your subscription, as the “Printed Mint on Printify” round shows.

The short version: Printify is the stronger all-rounder for most sellers, especially if you want product variety, global reach, and multi-channel flexibility.

Printed Mint carves out a niche for U.S.-focused brands that prioritize premium packaging and a curated product line, but its late-2024 shipping delays and thin review record are worth factoring into your decision.

Printify vs Printed Mint: Quick Verdict

1. Printify – Best overall for scaling a POD business Wide product catalog, 70+ print providers worldwide, multi-channel integrations, and a Premium plan that unlocks meaningful cost savings.

2. Printed Mint – Best for branded, gift-ready U.S. fulfillment Curated lifestyle catalog with strong packaging and branding options, though late 2024 brought shipping delays and communication complaints from some sellers.

3. Printed Mint through Printify – Best for Premium subscribers who want Printed Mint products With Printify Premium, the same Printed Mint candles cost less than Printed Mint’s own list price; on Printify’s free plan, buying direct gives you a lower product base price on every candle I priced, before shipping and packaging.

Quick Comparison: Printify vs Printed Mint

Get a clear overview of how these two POD platforms stack up before we dive into the details:

Feature Printify Printed Mint
Business model POD marketplace connecting 70+ print providers across 140+ print facilities U.S. POD brand fulfilling from Phoenix, Arizona; in-house production plus vetted partners for select items
Product catalog 2,000+ products across apparel, homeware, accessories, drinkware, supplements, and more Just under 300 products, marketed as 300+; focused on drinkware, candles, blankets, and giftable homeware
Shipping reach Global fulfillment through 140+ facilities U.S.-focused flat-rate shipping, plus Canada and international rates
Integrations Shopify, Etsy, TikTok Shop, Amazon, eBay, WooCommerce, Wix, Squarespace, BigCommerce, PrestaShop, API, Pop-Up Store Shopify, Etsy, TikTok, Order Desk; Amazon, WooCommerce, Walmart, and others through Order Desk
Pricing Free plan; Premium $39/month or $24.99/month billed yearly ($299/year) Free to use; per-item costs plus shipping; volume discounts up to 20%
Branding options White-label products; packaging customization varies by provider Free, Essentials, and Deluxe packaging tiers with labels, ribbon, and branded packing slips
Quality consistency Varies by provider; results depend on your chosen printer Users report mixed results by product line, with late-2024 complaints under holiday load
Support & ratings 24/7 merchant support; Trustpilot 4.4 (7,728 reviews); Shopify app 4.7 (4,369 reviews) Trustpilot 2.5 (30 reviews); Shopify app 3.0 (2 reviews)
Available on Printify? Not applicable Yes, with more than 30 products in its Printify catalog

Best for Product Variety: Printify

Printify Homepage

If you want the widest possible range of products to sell, Printify is the clear choice.

Its marketplace model connects you to 70+ print providers across 140+ print facilities, which translates to more than 2,000 customizable products spanning apparel, drinkware, home decor, pet products, stickers, accessories, and even supplements.

That variety comes with a trade-off, though. Because different providers handle different products, print quality and turnaround times aren’t uniform.

Printify’s Shopify app holds a 4.7 out of 5 rating from 4,369 reviews, but sellers also report inconsistent quality between providers. Order samples and vet your providers before committing to any product line.

Printed Mint candles

Printed Mint’s catalog sits just under 300 products (it markets 300+), with real strength in lifestyle products like mugs, tumblers, candles, blankets, and giftable homeware. Many long-term customers report excellent print quality, particularly on mugs and tumblers. But others have cited inconsistent prints, stock issues, and misprints as reasons for leaving.

Printed Mint produces in-house but sends select products to vetted partners, so mixed orders can carry separate tracking and shipping charges while support stays with Printed Mint. More than 30 products also appear on Printify under Printed Mint.

Seller reviews tell a split story: July 2025 reviews praise its custom branding and quick issue resolution, while reviews from the 2024 holiday rush flag late orders under heavy load. Monitor production times during busy periods rather than treating positive reviews as a guarantee.

Printify wins for product variety With 2,000+ products across dozens of categories and 70+ providers to choose from, Printify gives you far more flexibility to build and expand your product line. Printed Mint’s curated catalog works well for niche lifestyle brands, but it can’t match that breadth.

Best for Pricing and Margins: Split Decision

Both platforms let you sign up for free, which is a nice starting point. But the way they handle ongoing costs and margins is quite different.

Printify

Printify pricing

Printify’s free account includes its design tools and core integrations. Premium adds product discounts and more stores; choose it when your savings cover the subscription.

  • Free – $0, up to 5 stores, and 24/7 merchant support.
  • Premium – $39/month or $24.99/month billed yearly ($299/year); up to 20% off all products, up to 33% off new products and custom branding, and 10 stores.
  • Enterprise – Custom pricing, custom API integration, a dedicated account manager, and unlimited stores.

The monthly price rose from $29 in February 2026; Premium is non-refundable, so cancel before renewal if discounts stop covering it.

Base pricing across many SKUs is already competitive, especially when you cherry-pick lower-cost providers. And if you’re just testing ideas, Printify’s free pop-up shop builder lets you validate concepts without paying for a separate storefront subscription.

Printed Mint

Printed Mint is free to use with no subscription tier. You simply pay per product plus flat-rate shipping, and its biggest accounts unlock an Inner Circle volume discount of up to 20% off list. On the Printed Mint products I priced, its direct list prices came in below Printify’s free-plan prices for the same items.

Where Printed Mint justifies its pricing is through branding value. Its Essentials and Deluxe packaging tiers add labels, ribbon and branded packing slips for a fee, which can support higher retail pricing if your brand targets a premium audience. The downside: unlike Printify, there’s no free standalone storefront, so you’ll need an existing ecommerce presence on Shopify, Etsy, TikTok Shop, or another platform.

I priced the same Printed Mint candles both ways in the next round.

Split: Printed Mint direct wins on the free plan, Printify Premium wins at volume

If discounts cover $39 monthly, Premium and provider choice give you more margin levers. Below that, Printed Mint’s direct base prices win, although shipping can reverse the result.

Printed Mint on Printify: Buy Direct or Through Printify?

I priced the same 4oz tin candle on both platforms, and the cheapest base price depended on one subscription.

Printed Mint tin candles on Printify

Printed Mint fulfills Printify orders from Phoenix, Arizona, with more than 30 products. Its candle listings showed a 9.4 provider score and roughly 2.5 to 2.9 days average production, not guaranteed delivery times.

These prices are from November 11, 2026. Printify prices are “from” prices for the cheapest variant; confirm your exact size and finish before you set retail prices.

Product Printed Mint direct Printify free Printify Premium First-item U.S. shipping
Tin candle, 4oz $8.00 $8.94 $6.47 Printify $5.49 / Printed Mint $6.90
Scented candle, 4oz amber jar $8.00 $9.33 $7.33 Printify $6.19 / Printed Mint $6.90
Frosted glass candle, 11oz $18.00 $21.12 $16.63 Printify $9.39 / Printed Mint $8.99
Cutting board, small (approx.*) $20.00 ~$28 ~$20.40 Printify $15.19 / Printed Mint $14.65

Printify listed the cutting board in euros when I priced it; these dollar figures are approximate. Confirm the dollar total before ordering.

  • Direct beats Printify free on base price: Save $0.94 on the tin candle and $3.12 on the frosted candle.
  • Premium beats direct list on candles: Save $1.53 on the tin candle and $1.37 on the frosted candle.
  • Cutting boards favor direct: The small board costs less direct, even against Premium.
  • Inner Circle changes the comparison: Top-tier prices of $6.40 for the tin and $14.40 for the frosted candle beat Premium, but require roughly $150,000+ in yearly purchases.

Shipping reverses the tin-candle result: Printify free totals $14.43 versus $14.90 direct, about $0.47 less before extras. Direct stays cheaper landed than Printify free on the frosted candle and cutting board, and cheaper than Premium on the board.

Printed Mint offers free shipping on orders of $299+, except November 15 to December 31.

My break-even math below uses product costs only, excluding shipping, packaging, and tax:

  • Premium versus Printify free: Saving $2.47 per tin candle covers $39/month at about 16 candles, or $299/year at about 121.
  • Premium versus direct list: Saving $1.53 per tin candle covers the monthly fee at about 26 candles, or the annual fee at about 196.

Other Printify products count toward break-even. These candles’ Premium discounts were about 21% to 28%, above the “up to 20%” headline.

Through Printify, the trade-offs are:

  • Packaging: Printed Mint’s Essentials and Deluxe tiers belong to its direct dashboard; Printify orders use Printify’s branding options.
  • Volume discounts: Inner Circle applies to direct accounts.
  • Production: Printify doesn’t bypass Printed Mint’s queue. A late-2024 Etsy seller review reported delays through Printify too.
  • Channels: You gain Printify’s native connections and can mix Printed Mint products with other providers in one store.

Printed Mint announced select product price adjustments from October 20; check both platforms before setting retail prices.

Printify Premium wins for buying Printed Mint products at volume

For candle base-cost savings below about 26 monthly sales, favor direct. Choose direct for its packaging tiers, but compare landed costs: small-candle shipping can favor Printify without Premium.

Best for Integrations and Multi-Channel Selling: Printify

Printify connects to more sales channels without Order Desk:

  • Marketplaces: Etsy, TikTok Shop, Amazon, and eBay.
  • Storefronts: Shopify, WooCommerce, Wix, Squarespace, BigCommerce, and PrestaShop.
  • Other options: An API for custom setups and Printify Pop-Up Store.

That breadth makes it a natural fit for a multi-channel strategy where you want your products available everywhere your customers shop.

On top of that, Printify includes a design editor with AI image generation to speed up product creation, plus the pop-up shop builder I mentioned earlier for testing new ideas without a full ecommerce stack.

Printed Mint connects directly to Shopify, Etsy, and TikTok, and reaches Amazon, WooCommerce, BigCommerce, Faire, Wayfair, and Walmart only through Order Desk, so the native list is noticeably shorter. If your strategy revolves around two or three core channels and you don’t need the widest possible reach, that may not be a dealbreaker. But for sellers who want to be everywhere, Printify has the edge.

Order Desk is a separate order-routing tool you connect and manage yourself. For Printed Mint products on Amazon or eBay without Order Desk, use Printify instead.

Printify wins for integrations More native sales channels, a built-in design editor, and a free pop-up shop give Printify clear advantages for sellers pursuing a multi-channel approach. Printed Mint covers the basics but lacks the breadth.

Best for Branding and Packaging: Printed Mint

Printed Mint Homepage

This is where Printed Mint genuinely stands out. If your brand lives or dies on the unboxing experience, Printed Mint’s packaging capabilities are hard to match in the POD space.

The platform emphasizes elevated branding across the board: labels, ribbon, branded packing slips, and three packaging tiers designed for “gift-ready” orders.

  • Free – Default protective wrap, no outside label, and a packing slip with your company display name.
  • Essentials – A full-color 2.5-inch round outside label, ribbon, and crinkle paper.
  • Deluxe – Labels on each wrapped item too, your logo and a promo image on the packing slip, and more ribbon and crinkle colors.

Essentials and Deluxe add a per-order fee shown in your Printed Mint account; switch samples to Free packaging to avoid it.

Its design tools are tuned toward creating cohesive branded packaging experiences rather than just product prints. For sellers of candles, mugs, textiles, and other giftable products targeting U.S. buyers, that’s a compelling proposition.

Printify, by contrast, offers white-label products, but branding options like inserts, stickers, and custom packaging vary significantly depending on which print provider you use. Some providers offer decent branding; others offer very little.

If branding matters to you on Printify, you’ll need to specifically seek out providers that support it, and the options still won’t match what Printed Mint offers as standard.

Printify Premium discounts custom branding features by up to 33%, narrowing the cost gap. Printed Mint products ordered through Printify use Printify’s branding options, not Printed Mint’s direct packaging tiers.

Printed Mint wins for branding

Labels, branded slips, and gift-ready presentation are built into Printed Mint’s own dashboard. On Printify, branding support varies by provider and is generally more limited. If unboxing is central to your brand, Printed Mint has the stronger offering.

Best for Shipping and Fulfillment: Printify

Printify’s marketplace model means fulfillment happens across 140+ print facilities worldwide. You can route orders to providers based on proximity to your customers, giving you more geographic flexibility than Printed Mint’s Phoenix fulfillment center.

The trade-off is that shipping speed varies heavily depending on which provider you select and where your customer is located, so you need to set realistic expectations on your storefront.

Printed Mint shipping rates

Printed Mint offers automatic shipping selection and express production for U.S. orders, but its 2024 holiday season exposed delays.

Standard production runs 2 to 4+ business days. Express Production takes 1 to 2, rising to 3 to 4 between November 15 and December 31; Phoenix shipments use USPS, Asendia, and DHL.

Seller reviews from October and November 2024 describe orders taking nine days against a quoted four to six and repeated overdue orders, and Printed Mint itself apologized in January 2025 for extended production times over the holidays.

Positive July 2025 reviews don’t tell you how it handles a holiday rush. Test peak-season turnaround before promising delivery dates.

If your customers are primarily in the U.S. and Printed Mint is running smoothly, the fulfillment experience can be excellent. But that 2024 holiday record is hard to ignore, particularly for time-sensitive orders during peak seasons.

Printed Mint’s 2026 cutoffs for December 24 delivery are:

  • International standard: November 24.
  • Standard shipping: December 10.
  • Expedited shipping: December 15.
  • Express Production plus expedited: December 17.

Printify wins for shipping reliability

Global routing across 140+ print facilities gives Printify more flexibility and redundancy. Printed Mint’s U.S.-focused model has potential for fast domestic shipping, but its 2024 holiday delays showed how quickly that promise can slip.

Best for Support and Reliability: Printify

Neither platform offers perfect support, but the overall picture favors Printify at this point.

Printify

Printify and Printful announced their merger in November 2024, but still operate as separate brands under one holding company. Printful’s former CEO leads the combined business, with Printify’s CEO becoming President and Head of Platform. For sellers, signup still means separate accounts and separate catalogs.

Printify’s plans list 24/7 merchant support, with no phone line listed. Its Shopify app sits at 4.7 from 4,369 reviews, and Trustpilot shows 4.4 out of 5 from 7,728 reviews, with replies to every negative review.

Positive themes from users include accessibility for beginners, broad integrations, and the ability to choose and switch providers. The most common complaints center on quality variance when using cheaper providers and limited branding control.

Late-2025 Shopify reviewers describe valid addresses flagged as invalid, with support suggesting a provider switch. A December 2025 reviewer reported waiting on live chat without reaching an agent; Printify replied that it was expanding its support team. Those complaints don’t establish that the merger caused support problems, but they temper the strong overall ratings.

Printed Mint

Printed Mint’s reputation is more polarized. Its Trustpilot score still sits at 2.5 out of 5 from just 30 reviews, and its Shopify app holds 3.0 from 2 reviews, reflecting a split between sellers who had excellent experiences and those who had very negative ones.

On the positive side, some customers describe top-tier service and consistently high quality for specific product lines. On the negative side, complaints about poor communication, unresolved misprints, and integration issues appear frequently.

The 2024 holiday season was particularly rough. Seller reviews from that stretch describe late orders, constant overdues, and support promising dates that weren’t met, and Printed Mint later apologized for its extended holiday production times. For a platform whose pitch is premium quality and service, those are concerning signals.

When Printed Mint routes an item to a production partner, support still stays with Printed Mint.

Printify wins for support and reliability

Higher ratings from a far larger review base, a more established operational track record, and a support team Printify says it is expanding give Printify the edge, even with its late-2025 complaints. Printed Mint has passionate fans but its 2024 support and fulfillment issues create real risk for sellers who depend on consistent service.

How We Evaluated These Platforms

To make this comparison as useful as possible, I focused on the areas that matter most to POD sellers choosing between these two platforms. Here’s what I looked at and how I weighted each factor:

Evaluation Area What I Looked At Weight
Product Catalog Number and variety of customizable products, category coverage, and catalog depth 20%
Pricing and Margins Base product costs, matched Printed Mint items bought direct vs through Printify, subscription plans, available discounts, and shipping 20%
Integrations Number of native sales channels, marketplace connections, and built-in tools 15%
Branding and Packaging Custom packaging, inserts, packing slips, and white-label capabilities 15%
Shipping and Fulfillment Geographic reach, speed, routing flexibility, and recent reliability track record 15%
Support and Reputation App store ratings, Trustpilot scores, support channels, and 2024-2026 user feedback trends 15%

I priced the same Printed Mint products on printedmint.com and in Printify, on both the free and Premium plans, and compared first-item shipping to a U.S. address. Prices are current as of November 11, 2026. Compare exact variants before using these figures to set margins.

Printify vs Printed Mint: Our Verdict

For most POD sellers, Printify is the stronger platform. Its massive product catalog, global fulfillment network, competitive pricing with Premium discounts, and wide range of integrations make it the more versatile and scalable choice.

You’ll need to invest time vetting providers and ordering samples to manage quality, but that flexibility is also what makes it powerful.

Printed Mint still has a legitimate place for a specific type of seller: someone building a curated, gift-oriented brand for U.S. customers who values premium packaging and a polished unboxing experience.

The branding capabilities are genuinely impressive for a POD platform. But the operational issues reported around the 2024 holiday season, including shipping delays, communication breakdowns, and capacity strain, mean you’ll want to monitor fulfillment closely and have a backup plan for your best-selling SKUs during peak periods.

Already selling on Printify and want Printed Mint candles? Select Printed Mint as the provider and check Premium’s break-even against direct base prices, about 26 tin candles monthly; below that, or when packaging is the priority, compare a direct account’s landed costs.

If you’re just starting out or scaling across multiple channels, start with Printify. If branding is your top priority and you’re comfortable managing the fulfillment risk, Printed Mint is worth testing for a focused U.S. product line.

FAQ

Is Printed Mint on Printify?

Yes, Printed Mint is a Printify print provider fulfilling orders from Phoenix, Arizona. Its Printify range includes candles and giftable homeware, with more than 30 products across its catalog and shipping pages. Buying through Printify gives you Printify’s integrations, but not Printed Mint’s direct packaging tiers or Inner Circle discounts. See “Printed Mint on Printify: Buy Direct or Through Printify?” above.

Is Printify Premium worth it for Printed Mint products?

Yes, if your product discounts cover the subscription. On a 4oz tin candle, the $39 monthly plan breaks even at about 16 candles versus Printify free, or about 26 versus Printed Mint’s direct base price. The $299 annual plan lowers that threshold. These calculations exclude shipping and packaging, which can change the cheapest route.

How much does Printify Premium cost in 2026?

Printify Premium costs $39/month billed monthly, or an advertised $24.99/month billed yearly at $299. The monthly price rose from $29 in February 2026. Premium advertises up to 20% off all products and up to 33% off new products and custom branding. Subscriptions are non-refundable, so check your expected savings before renewing.

Does Printed Mint integrate with TikTok Shop and Amazon?

Printed Mint connects directly to TikTok Shop, but Amazon requires Order Desk. Shopify and Etsy also connect directly; additional marketplaces and ecommerce platforms use Order Desk as the routing layer. If you want Printed Mint products with native Amazon or eBay connections, buying them through Printify is another option. See “Best for Integrations and Multi-Channel Selling: Printify” above.

Did Printify and Printful merge?

Yes, Printify and Printful announced their merger in November 2024. They continue operating as separate brands under one holding company, with separate accounts and catalogs. Printful’s former CEO leads the combined business, while Printify’s CEO became President and Head of Platform. A Printify account therefore does not automatically become a Printful account or give you its catalog.

Published by

Raul is an editor and content curator focused on AI, SaaS, and ecommerce platforms. He researches emerging trends, develops in-depth guides and reviews, and works with contributors to deliver clear, practical insights that help readers navigate modern tech.

2 Comments

  1. You based all of your Printed Mint review on *at least* year old information making this review stale and totally unreliable. If you had (as i have just done) manually compared prices between Printed Mint directly and Printed Mint through Printify (even with Printify Premium), you’d see that Printed Mint wins on price. Customer Support through Printify has tanked since the merger and was basically useless last holiday season, and all you did was look at old online infomrmation doing no work yourself to get reliable current information.

    1. Thanks for pushing on this, you were right that the pricing section was out of date. I re-priced Printed Mint products both ways on November 11, 2026: buying direct beats Printify’s free plan on every candle I checked, while Premium undercuts Printed Mint’s list price on candles once you sell roughly 26 a month. I’ve added a full direct-vs-through-Printify price table, updated Premium to its current $39/month, and rewrote the support section to cover the Printful merger and the late-2025 support complaints. Appreciate you taking the time to check it yourself.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

shopify-one-dollar-promo-3-months
Close the CTA